3Commas is a toolbox: many bot types, several exchanges and a full trading terminal so you can build your own strategy. Jarvis goes the other way: five ready, versioned models, one position at a time, and every performance number shown with its sample, window and label. One gives you freedom; the other gives you discipline and measurement.
| What we compare | Jarvis | 3Commas |
|---|---|---|
| Where the money sits | In your own Binance account. Jarvis never moves your balance out of it. | On the exchange you connect; they state they cannot withdraw your funds. |
| API key permissions | Read balance and trade only, never withdraw. The key is stored AES-256-GCM encrypted. | A key you create on your exchange; they state they have no withdrawal access. |
| Testing without risk | The first version runs only on a Binance Demo account, with test money. | Demo Trading with US$ 10,000 virtual, up to 2 accounts, perpetual markets only. |
| How numbers are shown | Always with sample, window and a simulated or live label; small samples are stated. | Backtest up to 1 year on paid plans; they warn it cannot predict the future. |
| Telegram signals | The signal reaches your Telegram before anything is executed. | Official Telegram bot with entries, exits, errors and a daily summary. |
| Models and comparison | Five versioned models compared over the same window and the same sample. | DCA, Grid, Signal Bot and SmartTrade; the comparison is up to you. |
| Entry price | Price is not published on this page; the first version runs on Demo only. | No free plan; Starter US$ 15/month on promo (checked on 10/10/2026). |
3Commas data checked on 10 October 2026 on their official pricing pages and documentation. Prices and features change: check the source before deciding.
In Jarvis no number stands alone: it comes with the sample, the window and a simulated or live label. If the sample is small, the screen says so instead of showing a percentage. 3Commas warns that backtesting cannot predict the future, but that is a general notice, not a label attached to each number.
Jarvis keeps one position at a time, with stop and target set on entry. That makes it clear which model took which decision. With DCA, Grid and SmartTrade all running in one dashboard, that reading is harder.
The Binance key Jarvis uses only needs permission to read your balance and to trade. It is stored AES-256-GCM encrypted and the money never leaves your account. 3Commas also states it cannot withdraw; the difference is that in Jarvis the minimum permission set is the default.
You set the minimum confidence Jarvis needs in order to enter. Below that the signal still reaches your Telegram and nothing is executed. It is a brake you control, not a bot parameter to calibrate.
Pick 3Commas if
Choose 3Commas if you want to build several bot types, across several exchanges, and feed in external TradingView signals.
Pick Jarvis if
Choose Jarvis if you prefer five ready models, one position at a time, and every number shown with sample, window and label.
Turn the bots off and revoke, on Binance, the API key you had given to 3Commas, then create a new one with read-balance and trade permissions only, no withdrawal. Paste that key into Jarvis, pick a model and a minimum confidence, and start on the Demo account.
No. The key you create only needs permission to read your balance and to trade, never to withdraw. It is stored AES-256-GCM encrypted and the money stays in your account.
3Commas, by a wide margin: DCA, Grid, Signal Bot and SmartTrade, across several exchanges. Jarvis has five versioned models and one position at a time, designed to be compared against each other.
Not yet. The first version runs only on a Binance Demo account, with test money. That is deliberate, so there is measured history before real money is involved.
Yes. 3Commas has Demo Trading with US$ 10,000 in virtual funds, up to two accounts and perpetual markets only. Jarvis, in its first version, runs exclusively on a Binance Demo account.
It takes a few minutes to see it working with your own eyes.